Brand Wars: Vanilla Bean Buttercream (Scentsy) vs. Vanilla Bean (ScentSationals)

Time for Brand Wars! In this series, we’ll be comparing and contrasting similar scents across various brands. We will not only look at the scents themselves, but also upfront costs, value, and performance.


Comparison Scentsy Vanilla Bean Buttercream With ScentSationals Vanilla Bean wax melts candles

This week’s contestants:

  • Vanilla Bean Buttercream from Scentsy ~ Decadent buttercream frosting made with the freshest butter whipped with cane sugar and vanilla extract. So creamy and sweet you will have to lick the spoon!
  • Vanilla Bean from ScentSationals ~ Good, old-fashioned vanilla

Reason for Comparison: A comparison of two basic vanilla bean scents. I also wanted to compare the pricier Scentsy melt to the bargain ScentSationals brand.

The Showdown

Round 1: Upfront Cost

The Scentsy wax bar is 2.6 ounces net weight, selling for $5 per package. That makes the cost here $1.92 per ounce.

The ScentSationals wax melt cost me $2 at Wal-Mart. Since it weighs in at 2.5 ounces, that makes it cost 80¢ per ounce.

Winner: ScentSationals

Round 2: Value


For this round, I compared how many ounces of each scent that I needed to get comparable scent throws. For the Scentsy bar, I used 3 pieces, or just under 1 ounce of wax. I found I needed to use a little more from my ScentSationals pack – still 3 cubes, but that weighed in at 1.25 ounces.

Bottom line? I needed to use more of the ScentSationals wax to get a similar scent strength to the Scentsy wax. Even though I paid more for the Scentsy wax melt up front, the overall value ended up being better from Scentsy. I would have to use less wax per melting session. Even though the longevity for the ScentSationals wax melt was a bit longer (see below), it wasn’t significant enough to change my opinion of the overall value.

Winner: Scentsy

Round 3: Scent

This round is based more on personal preference. Both scents had this artificial vanilla smell to them on cold sniff. I didn’t think I would care for either one on cold sniff alone. However, they both turned out to be pretty good once melted. Vanilla Bean Buttercream from Scentsy was creamy and buttery with a good amount of sweetness to it. I found it delicious!

Vanilla Bean from ScentSationals was more of a straight up vanilla scent. It had a little bit of a play-dough smell to it that I didn’t care for – more at the end whiffs. More sweet and less creamy than Vanilla Bean Buttercream.

Winner: Scentsy

Round 4: Strength

Both vanillas were on the lighter side, which I’m used to for most vanilla scents. Vanilla Bean Buttercream (Scentsy), though, was stronger than Vanilla Bean (ScentSationals). I also found the throw much better for Vanilla Bean Buttercream.

Winner: Scentsy



Round 5: Longevity

Here’s where the ScentSationals wax melt edged out Scentsy. Neither lasted a super long time (about 7 hours for Scentsy and 8 hours for ScentSationals), but I expected the Scentsy wax melt to last longer given the investment.

Winner: ScentSationals

Overall Winner: Vanilla Bean Buttercream, Scentsy

ScentSationals Vanilla Bean Buttercream Wax Melts


Click here to read our prior review of Scentsy’s Vanilla Bean Buttercream. 

Have any Brand War suggestions? Use the contact form to let me know!


Happy candle burning ~

Andrea Haskins

Candle Scoop – The best smelling blog around!

Author: Andrea

Andrea is the voice behind Candle Scoop. She is a long-standing member of Candlefind and loves all things scented. While she enjoys scents across the spectrum, she is a die-hard bakery and fresh-scent fan. She enjoys rooting out bargains and candle discounts, but she won't hesitate to pamper herself with a luxury brand. When not writing or talking about candles, she enjoys spectator sports and playing with her pups. Andrea would love to hear from you, so don't hesitate to contact!

Share This Post On


  1. I am reluctant to say it, but I never buy plain vanillas anymore! There is just so much out there to try, most of which is more interesting. Thanks anyway; I do think vanilla augments a lot of scents, making them better.

    Post a Reply
  2. I am a Scentsy girl and always will be but I appreciate your honest review! I love the Scentsy Vanilla Bean Buttercream, it’s mellow and makes my kitchen smell great.

    Post a Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest